You open Google Maps, type in “roofer near me,” and there it is. The company that opened a couple of years after you is sitting in the top three. You’ve got more experience, you do better work, and you’re nowhere near the top of the list. It stings.
Here’s the good news. Google Maps rankings aren’t random, and they aren’t a popularity contest you lost for good. There are specific reasons your competitor shows up first, and most of them are things you can fix. In this article I’ll walk you through what’s actually going on and how to rank higher on Google Maps in your area.
Key Takeaways
- Google ranks local results on three things: relevance, distance, and prominence. Nobody can pay their way into the organic Maps results.
- Your primary Google Business Profile category is the biggest ranking lever local SEO experts point to.
- Distance matters a lot, but a stronger profile can win searches beyond your immediate neighborhood.
- Reviews count in three ways: your rating, how many you have, and how recent they are.
- Your website supports your Google Business Profile through consistent business information and helpful, relevant service pages.
How Google Decides Who Shows Up First
Google is pretty open about the basics. In its Business Profile help article on improving local ranking, Google says local results come down mainly to three things:
- Relevance: how well your profile matches what someone searched for.
- Distance: how far your business is from the person searching.
- Prominence: how well known your business is, based on things like your reviews and how many other websites link to you.
Google also says there’s no way to request or pay for a better local ranking. Ads in Maps carry a “Sponsored” label, but the regular results are earned. If your competitor is above you there, they’re beating you on one or more of those three factors.
Google doesn’t publish the full formula, but Whitespark’s 2026 Local Search Ranking Factors report had 47 local SEO experts score 187 Google Maps ranking factors. It’s expert opinion, not Google’s data, but it lines up with what I see when I audit home service businesses.
Their Category Is a Better Match
If I could only look at one thing on your profile, it would be your primary category. It’s how you tell Google what kind of business you are, and the experts in Whitespark’s survey ranked it the number one factor for Maps rankings.
This is where a lot of businesses lose without realizing it. A roofer listed under a general “Contractor” category is telling Google they do a little bit of everything. The competitor listed as “Roofing contractor” is telling Google exactly what they do. Guess who shows up when someone searches for a roofer?
Additional categories matter too, landing at number eight on the same list. So do the predefined services Google suggests inside your profile. Pick the categories and services that match the jobs you actually want more of. Then look at the businesses ranking above you. Their primary category shows right on their listing, so you’re not guessing.
They’re Closer to the Person Searching
Proximity scored second in the survey, right behind category. Google wants to show people businesses near them. If someone searches from a neighborhood two miles from your competitor’s address and fifteen miles from yours, your competitor has a head start you can’t completely erase.
That’s also why your ranking changes depending on where the search happens. You might be number one from your driveway and invisible across town.
You can’t move your shop, and fake addresses are a fast way to get suspended. What you can do is improve your Google Maps ranking by getting strong on relevance and prominence, so you win searches farther from your address.
Their Business Name Has the Keyword in It
Keywords in the business name came in third. That one’s frustrating, because the honest fix isn’t renaming yourself “Best Local Roofing Pros.” Google’s guidelines say the name on your profile should match your real-world business name, the one on your sign, your trucks, and your paperwork. Stuffing in extra keywords breaks the rules and can get you suspended.
What about a competitor who padded their name? If their listing doesn’t match their real business name, you can suggest an edit on their profile in Google Maps. The survey experts even listed spam removal as a ranking factor. Clear out a keyword-stuffed listing above you and you move up a spot.
They Have More Reviews, and Newer Ones
Reviews show up all over the top of the list. A high Google rating ranked sixth, the number of Google reviews ninth, and how recent those reviews are came in at eleventh. A steady flow of reviews over time also scored higher than big bursts.
Customers care about the same things. In BrightLocal’s 2026 Local Consumer Review Survey of 1,002 U.S. consumers, 47% said they won’t use a business with fewer than 20 reviews, and 74% said they only care about reviews written in the last three months. The share who will only use a business rated 4.5 stars or higher jumped to 31%, up from 17% the year before.
So a competitor with 80 reviews and a few from last week may have an advantage over your 40 glowing reviews from two years ago. The fix is simple: ask every happy customer, right after the job. I break down how to do that in my guide on how to get more Google reviews. And reply to every review you get. BrightLocal found 89% of consumers expect business owners to respond.
They’re Open When the Search Happens
This one surprises people. Whether your business is open at the moment someone searches was a brand new factor in Whitespark’s survey, and it went straight to number five. If your profile says you close at 5, you can start sliding down the list around closing time, and businesses that are still open take your spot.
People search for a plumber at 9 at night. If your competitor offers emergency services and their Google Business Profile accurately reflects those hours, they may have an advantage in those searches. Make sure your listed hours reflect when your business is actually open, including evenings or weekends if you offer those services. Don’t extend your hours just to improve rankings.
Their Website Backs Up Their Profile
Your Google Business Profile doesn’t rank on its own. Google also looks at the website it links to. The survey experts ranked your name, address, and phone matching between your site and your profile at 15th, keywords in the title tag of the page your profile links to at 17th, and having a dedicated page for each service at 24th.
A lot of contractors have a one-page site that says “we do roofing, siding, and gutters” in one paragraph. Their competitor has separate pages for roof replacement, roof repair, and gutters. Those dedicated pages help Google better understand what services the business offers and can improve its visibility in local search results. While they don’t guarantee higher Google Maps rankings, they help build a stronger foundation for local SEO.
If your phone number or address isn’t the same across your website, your profile, and other directories, fix that too. I explain why in this post on NAP consistency and local SEO. And if your site is outdated or thin, a professionally designed website built for local search can strengthen your overall online presence and support your Google Business Profile.
How to Rank Higher on Google Maps
First, make sure you’re actually showing up. If you can’t find your business on Maps at all, start with why your business isn’t showing up on Google Maps, because that’s a different problem. If you are showing up, just below the competition, here’s the order I’d tackle Google Business Profile optimization and everything around it:
- Check your primary category. Use the most specific one that matches your main service, then add relevant additional categories and services.
- Fill out every section of your profile. Hours, service areas, services, photos of real jobs, and a description that sounds like you.
- Build a review habit. Ask after every completed job and reply to every review within a few days.
- Match your info everywhere. Same name, address, and phone number on your site, your profile, and every directory.
- Give each service its own page. Link your profile to a page that clearly says what you do and where you do it.
- Check rankings from more than one spot. A ranking grid shows where you’re winning and losing across your whole service area, not just from your office.
One thing I’d skip: stuffing keywords into your profile description. The Whitespark experts ranked keywords in the description 171st out of 187 factors. Write it for customers, not for Google.
None of this is magic. It’s the everyday work of local SEO for small businesses, and it’s what we do every month in our local SEO service. It isn’t a one-time fix, because the businesses above you aren’t standing still either.
FAQ
Can I pay Google to rank higher on Maps?
No. Google says there’s no way to request or pay for a better local ranking. You can run ads that show up in Maps with a “Sponsored” label, but those are separate from the regular results and disappear when you stop paying.
How long does it take to move up on Google Maps?
It depends on your market and where you’re starting. Fixing something like the wrong primary category can sometimes make a difference fairly quickly. Reviews, website content, and overall prominence build over months, not days.
What matters more, my star rating or how many reviews I have?
Both matter, and so does recency. The experts ranked rating slightly above review count, but neither helps much if your newest review is a year old. Aim for a steady stream of fresh reviews, not one big push.
Why do I rank well near my office but not across town?
That’s distance at work. Google ranks results based on where the searcher is, so rankings can change from one neighborhood to the next. A stronger profile and website are how you widen the area where you show up.
See Exactly Why They’re Beating You
Every market is different. The reason your competitor outranks you might be your category, your reviews, your website, or all three. Guessing wastes time. Figuring out how to rank higher on Google Maps starts with knowing exactly what’s holding you back.
That’s what our free audit is for. We’ll look at your Google Business Profile, your reviews, and your website, and show you what to fix first. No pressure and no long sales pitch. Get your Free Online Presence Audit and find out where you stand. If you want to see what ongoing help looks like, our pricing is right there on the site too.